Manchester United’s Midfield Reinvention: Who Can Partner Mainoo and Ugarte for Success?

Manchester United’s 2024-25 season has been a rollercoaster, marked by flashes of brilliance and frustrating inconsistency. Sitting 16th in the Premier League as of May 2025, the Red Devils are a shadow of the dominant force that once ruled English football. Yet, under new head coach Ruben Amorim, appointed in November 2024, there’s a palpable sense of optimism. With a Europa League final appearance against Tottenham on the horizon, United are at a crossroads, poised for a major squad overhaul in the summer of 2025. Central to this transformation is the midfield, a department that has struggled for balance and dynamism.

Amorim’s vision hinges on building around young stars Kobbie Mainoo and Manuel Ugarte, but the duo needs a third piece—a dynamic, experienced midfielder to complete the engine room. This article delves into United’s midfield reinvention, examining the tactical demands of Amorim’s 3-4-3/3-4-2-1 system, the profiles of Mainoo and Ugarte, and the top transfer targets who could elevate United’s fortunes. From Premier League standouts to emerging talents, we’ll explore who could be the key to unlocking United’s potential in the 2025-26 season.

The State of United’s Midfield: A Need for Change

Manchester United’s midfield has been a problem area for years, plagued by inconsistency, injuries, and a lack of cohesion. The 2024-25 season exposed these flaws starkly, with United’s 16th-place standing reflecting a squad ill-suited to Amorim’s high-intensity, possession-based system. The departure of veterans like Christian Eriksen, whose contract expires in June 2025, and the uncertain future of Casemiro, who is in the final year of his deal, have left gaps that demand immediate attention.

Amorim’s preferred 3-4-3 formation requires a midfield that can dominate possession, break up opposition play, and transition quickly into attack. Currently, Kobbie Mainoo and Manuel Ugarte are seen as the foundation, but their partnership alone lacks the creativity and energy needed to compete with the Premier League’s elite. The club’s hierarchy, backed by Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s INEOS group, has allocated a transfer budget of nearly £100 million for the summer, with a central midfielder among the priority targets alongside a striker and playmaker.

The challenges are clear: United’s midfield lacks players who can both build play and cover ground effectively. Recent matches, such as the loss to West Ham in May 2025, highlighted Mainoo’s struggles in a No. 10 role and Ugarte’s occasional lapses in possession. To address these issues, Amorim is seeking a versatile midfielder who can complement the duo’s strengths, bringing balance and dynamism to the engine room.

Kobbie Mainoo: The Rising Star

Kobbie Mainoo, at just 20 years old, is Manchester United’s brightest young talent. The Stockport-born midfielder burst onto the scene in 2023, earning plaudits for his composure, ball-carrying, and defensive nous. In the 2024-25 season, he’s featured in 30 matches across all competitions, scoring three goals and providing two assists by May 2025. His ability to dictate tempo and break lines with progressive passes makes him a natural fit for Amorim’s system, particularly in a deeper midfield role.

However, Mainoo’s stop-start campaign, marred by a muscle injury and positional tweaks, has raised questions about his ideal role. Amorim initially deployed him as a No. 10, but his performances improved when shifted back to a deeper position alongside Bruno Fernandes or Casemiro. Against West Ham, Mainoo struggled in the advanced role, looking “notably lost” before being dropped deeper, where his ball-winning and distribution shone. His qualities—calmness under pressure, dribbling, and tenacity—suggest he’s best suited as a No. 8 or box-to-box midfielder, but he needs a partner who can unlock his attacking potential.

Mainoo’s contract situation adds complexity. He reportedly rejected United’s initial offer for a new deal, and with his current terms running until 2027, there’s speculation he could be sold if the price is right. Yet, Amorim views him as “untouchable,” alongside Fernandes and Diogo Dalot, signaling his centrality to the rebuild. The right midfield partner could help Mainoo thrive, allowing him to focus on progressive play while others handle defensive duties.

Manuel Ugarte: The Defensive Anchor

Signed from Paris Saint-Germain in the summer of 2024 for £50 million, Manuel Ugarte was hailed as the ideal foil for Mainoo. The 24-year-old Uruguayan brings tenacity, tackling, and relentless energy, qualities that align with Amorim’s high-pressing philosophy. In 28 appearances this season, Ugarte has averaged 3.2 tackles and 1.8 interceptions per game, making him a vital shield for United’s back three.

Yet, Ugarte’s adaptation has been uneven. Matches like the loss to West Ham, where he was dispossessed for a goal, and early struggles against Athletic Bilbao, where he was caught in possession, exposed his limitations on the ball. His passing accuracy (82%) lags behind elite defensive midfielders, and he’s not a natural playmaker. Amorim’s 3-4-3 demands that the central centre-back occasionally steps into midfield, reducing Ugarte’s need to orchestrate play, but he still requires a creative partner to offset his defensive focus.

Ugarte’s role as the primary No. 6 is secure, but his effectiveness hinges on the players around him. A midfielder who can link defense and attack, covering ground while adding flair, would allow Ugarte to focus on breaking up play, creating a balanced trio with Mainoo.

Amorim’s Tactical Vision: The Ideal Midfield Profile

Ruben Amorim’s 3-4-3 or 3-4-2-1 system is built on overloads and fluidity. His midfielders must be versatile, capable of defending, building play, and contributing to attacks. The setup typically features:

• Three centre-backs, with the wide ones carrying the ball forward to outnumber opponents in midfield.

• Two wing-backs, who stretch the pitch and support attacks.

• Two central midfielders, one sitting deeper (Ugarte) and one more dynamic (Mainoo).

• Two No. 10s or attacking midfielders, often Bruno Fernandes and another, to create chances.

The missing piece is a midfielder who can bridge Ugarte’s defensive solidity and Mainoo’s progressive play. This player should possess:

• Energy and Work Rate: To cover ground and press relentlessly.

• Creativity: To provide key passes and unlock defenses.

• Defensive Nous: To complement Ugarte’s ball-winning.

• Versatility: To adapt to Amorim’s fluid system, potentially playing as a No. 8 or second pivot.

With Eriksen leaving and Casemiro’s future uncertain, United’s transfer chiefs, including technical director Jason Wilcox, have prioritized a central midfielder alongside a striker and playmaker. The budget, potentially boosted by Europa League success, allows for a marquee signing, but financial fair play rules mean sales of players like Casemiro, Luke Shaw, or even Mainoo could fund the move.

Top Transfer Targets for 2025

United’s transfer strategy for summer 2025 is bold, with Amorim demanding “brave” moves to reshape the squad. The club is eyeing several midfielders who fit the profile of a dynamic, creative partner for Mainoo and Ugarte. Below are the top candidates, each assessed for their suitability.

1. Ederson (Atalanta)

The 25-year-old Brazilian midfielder has caught United’s attention after a standout season with Atalanta. Ederson’s box-to-box dynamism, averaging 2.5 tackles, 1.5 interceptions, and 1.2 key passes per game in Serie A, makes him a perfect fit for Amorim’s system. His ability to break up play and drive forward aligns with Mainoo’s style, while his physicality complements Ugarte’s tenacity.

Ederson’s £40 million valuation is within United’s budget, and his experience in high-pressing systems under Gian Piero Gasperini suggests he could adapt quickly. However, competition from Liverpool and Arsenal could complicate the deal. His versatility to play as a No. 8 or deeper pivot makes him a prime target to complete United’s midfield trio.

2. Adam Wharton (Crystal Palace)

Crystal Palace’s 21-year-old star Adam Wharton is another name on United’s radar. The England international, valued at £50 million, has impressed with his composure and passing range, averaging 86% pass accuracy and 2.1 key passes per game in the Premier League. His ability to dictate play from deep and contribute defensively (2.3 tackles per game) makes him a natural partner for Ugarte, allowing Mainoo to push forward.

Wharton’s youth aligns with United’s focus on building a squad for the future, and Amorim has reportedly approved his signing. However, Palace’s reluctance to sell and interest from Tottenham could drive up his price. His potential to grow alongside Mainoo makes him an exciting long-term prospect.

3. Jobe Bellingham (Sunderland)

At just 19, Jobe Bellingham, brother of Real Madrid’s Jude, is a bold option for United. The Sunderland midfielder has made over 40 appearances in the Championship this season, showcasing versatility across attacking and central midfield roles. His 1.8 key passes and 1.5 dribbles per game highlight his creativity, while his work rate suits Amorim’s high-pressing system.

Valued at £20 million, Bellingham represents a low-risk, high-reward signing, especially alongside teammate Chris Rigg, a 17-year-old United are also monitoring. The challenge is his lack of top-flight experience, which could delay his impact. Nonetheless, his potential to develop into a star makes him a compelling target.

4. Franco Mastantuono (River Plate)

United’s interest in 17-year-old River Plate prodigy Franco Mastantuono has been thwarted by Paris Saint-Germain, who have entered the race for the £37 million-rated attacking midfielder. Mastantuono’s flair, vision, and 2.2 key passes per game in Argentina’s Primera División make him a potential No. 10, but his versatility allows him to drop deeper alongside Mainoo and Ugarte.

His youth and inexperience pose risks, but United’s history of nurturing South American talents like Ángel Di María could make this a coup. PSG’s involvement complicates matters, but Amorim’s Portuguese connections and United’s global pull could sway the teenager.

5. Matheus Cunha (Wolverhampton Wanderers)

While primarily a forward, Wolves’ Matheus Cunha has been linked as a versatile option who could play as a No. 10 or attacking midfielder in Amorim’s system. The 25-year-old Brazilian, valued at £60 million, has scored eight goals and provided six assists in the Premier League this season. His energy, dribbling, and goal threat could add a new dimension to United’s midfield.

Former United star Ryan Giggs has endorsed Cunha’s signing, believing he could thrive alongside Mainoo and Ugarte. However, his higher valuation and United’s priority for a striker may limit this move unless sales generate additional funds. Cunha’s adaptability makes him a wildcard worth considering.

Why the Right Signing is Crucial

The midfield signing will define United’s 2025-26 season. Amorim’s system relies on overloads, with midfielders creating numerical advantages and linking play. Without a player who can bridge Ugarte’s defensive work and Mainoo’s progressive runs, United risk being overrun by rivals like Manchester City or Arsenal, who boast balanced midfields.

The Europa League final against Tottenham on May 21, 2025, offers a chance to secure Champions League qualification, boosting United’s budget and appeal to top targets. A victory could provide the financial muscle to pursue players like Ederson or Wharton, while a loss might force reliance on cheaper options like Bellingham. Either way, the new midfielder must integrate quickly to avoid another transitional season.

The signing’s impact extends beyond tactics. A high-profile addition could galvanize the squad and fans, signaling United’s ambition to reclaim their place among Europe’s elite. Mainoo and Ugarte, both young and adaptable, need a partner who can elevate their game, much like Paul Scholes and Roy Keane once complemented each other. The right player could transform United’s midfield into a unit capable of dominating possession, breaking down defenses, and competing for silverware.

Challenges and Considerations

United’s transfer plans face hurdles. Financial fair play rules necessitate sales, with players like Casemiro, Luke Shaw, and even Mainoo potentially on the chopping block if offers are substantial. The club’s “fire sale” approach, with only Fernandes, Harry Maguire, Amad, and Patrick Dorgu deemed untouchable, reflects a need to balance the books while funding new signings.

Competition is another obstacle. Liverpool’s interest in Ederson, Tottenham’s pursuit of Wharton, and PSG’s move for Mastantuono highlight the Premier League’s cutthroat transfer market. Amorim’s insistence on players committed to United’s project—evident in his dismissal of Viktor Gyökeres’ Champions League-driven interest—adds a layer of complexity. The new midfielder must buy into Amorim’s vision, even if United miss out on Champions League football.

Tactical fit is critical. Mainoo’s struggles as a No. 10 and Ugarte’s limitations in possession underscore the need for a player who can adapt to multiple roles. Amorim’s willingness to tweak his system, as seen in Mainoo’s positional shifts, suggests flexibility, but the new signing must hit the ground running to avoid disrupting the squad’s rhythm.

The Road Ahead: A New Era for United’s Midfield

As United prepare for the 2025-26 season, the midfield overhaul is a cornerstone of Amorim’s rebuild. A trio of Ugarte, Mainoo, and a new signing—be it Ederson’s dynamism, Wharton’s composure, or Bellingham’s potential—could provide the balance United have lacked. The club’s transfer chiefs are working tirelessly, with targets like Chris Rigg and Enzo Kana-Biyik also in the frame, signaling a blend of youth and experience.

Amorim’s job security depends on results, but the club’s backing, even after a potential Europa League final loss, gives him time to implement his vision. The new midfielder will be a statement of intent, a player who can elevate United from mid-table mediocrity to title contenders. With Mainoo’s flair and Ugarte’s grit as the foundation, the final piece could unlock a new era of success at Old Trafford.

Conclusion

Manchester United stand at a pivotal moment. Ruben Amorim’s appointment has brought hope, but the 2024-25 season’s struggles highlight the urgent need for a midfield reinvention. Kobbie Mainoo and Manuel Ugarte are the cornerstones, but their partnership lacks the creativity and energy needed to compete at the highest level. The summer of 2025 offers a chance to change that, with targets like Ederson, Adam Wharton, and Jobe Bellingham in the frame to complete the midfield trio.

This signing is more than a transfer—it’s a declaration of United’s ambition to reclaim their place among football’s elite. The right midfielder could transform the team’s dynamics, allowing Mainoo to shine and Ugarte to anchor with confidence. As the Red Devils prepare for a defining season, the search for the perfect partner is a journey that could redefine Manchester United’s future. Who would you choose to complete United’s midfield? Share your thoughts below!

FAQs

1. Why is Manchester United focusing on midfield in 2025?

   
   

   The midfield lacks balance, with Mainoo and Ugarte needing a creative, dynamic partner to thrive in Amorim’s system.

2. Who are United’s current midfielders?

   
   

   Key players include Kobbie Mainoo, Manuel Ugarte, Bruno Fernandes, Casemiro, and Christian Eriksen, though the latter two may leave.

3. What type of midfielder does Amorim want?

   
   

   A versatile, energetic player with creativity, defensive nous, and the ability to cover ground in a 3-4-3 system.

4. Who is the top transfer target?

   
   

   Atalanta’s Ederson is a prime candidate due to his box-to-box dynamism and fit for Amorim’s tactics.

5. Could Kobbie Mainoo leave United?

   
   

   While possible if a big offer arrives, Amorim considers him untouchable, central to the club’s future.

6. What’s Manuel Ugarte’s role in the team?

   
   

   Ugarte is the defensive anchor, focusing on tackles and interceptions in the No. 6 role.

7. How much is United’s transfer budget?

   
   

   Nearly £100 million, potentially boosted by Europa League success or player sales.

8. Why did United struggle in 2024-25?

   
   

   Injuries, tactical mismatches, and a lack of midfield quality contributed to their 16th-place standing.

9. Can young players like Jobe Bellingham make an impact?

   
   

   Yes, but their lack of top-flight experience may delay their contribution compared to proven stars.

10. How will a new midfielder help United?

    
    

    They’ll add creativity and balance, unlocking Mainoo’s potential and supporting Ugarte’s defensive work.